Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff LLP Benesch, Friedlander, Coplan & Aronoff LLP
PeopleServices

Menu

  • People
  • Services
  • Resources
  • Locations
  • Careers
  • About
  • Contact
New Hampshire Joins Data Protection Trend, Passes Comprehensive Data Protection Law
  1. Services
  2. Litigation

Product Liability

At Benesch, we approach product liability defense with the understanding that the future of an entire product line, and sometimes an entire company, can hinge upon finding the right litigation strategy.

Our product liability litigators consider not only the pending case, but its long-lasting implications on our clients’ businesses and method of doing business. Accordingly, our product liability team has extensive experience in regulatory compliance and claims prevention as well as in vigorous claims defense. In addition, our attorneys monitor nationwide developments in product liability litigation and product recalls to spot trends and reduce the number and size of future claims.

Our attorneys have been involved in the formation and orchestration of product safety committee meetings and product liability programs, record retention programs, reviews of product warnings, reviews of privilege of critical self-analysis issues and recall procedures. In addition, we have experience in responding to inquiries and investigations of both federal and state regulatory agencies. We have conducted internal seminars for claims departments and engineering departments of our insurance and manufacturing clients.

We are experienced in a wide variety of products and industries, including, among others:

  • Medical devices
  • Pharmaceuticals and vaccines
  • Engines and generators
  • Maritime products
  • Industrial equipment
  • Electrical appliances
  • Power tools and other consumer goods
  • Chemicals
  • Asbestos, benzene, and toxic torts
  • Vehicles

Product Liability Litigation

Our litigators have handled product liability claims in courts throughout the country, in ADR negotiations, and in both domestic and international arbitrations. We work side-by-side with our clients to maximize the cost savings that can be achieved through effective case management and discovery. Our litigators use technology whenever possible to benefit our clients and can effectively guide clients through electronic discovery issues. We offer not only a team of skilled trial attorneys, but also a group which has in-depth product liability experience, including:

  • Successful defense of actions brought against medical device insureds/manufacturers, including catheters, implantable pumps, prosthetics and replacements, ambulatory equipment and remote-controlled surgical devices, laser surgical devices, vaccines, and pharmaceuticals.
  • Extensive experience with fire origination and causation determination and in defending product manufacturers in cases involving fire damage claims.
  • Coordination of large, complex multiparty cases involving engine and generator manufacturers and suppliers, asbestos toxic tort defendants, and cordless telephone and appliance product manufacturers.
  • Defense of multimillion-dollar actions brought against manufacturers and distributors of construction and building materials.

Medical Devices

Benesch has deep experience defending medical device companies in product liability defense matters and counseling in intellectual property matters. On the defense side, we have been involved in numerous medical device litigation and product liability defense matters, including toxic tort litigation, repetitive stress injury litigation, general liability, workers’ compensation, and pharmaceutical liability litigation. Our team has litigated product liability claims involving a variety of biotech/life science products, including Cough Syrup Additives, Forceps, Diet Supplements, Implantable Morphine Pumps, Cardiac Surgery Equipment, Aortic Direct Ellipse Cannulae, Laser Hair Removal Apparatus, Cold Packs, Ear Piercing Apparatus, Loftstrand Crutches, Home Oxygen Tanks, Weight Loss Devices/Home Health Equipment, Spinal Catheters, Ephedra, Wheelchair Lifts, Pharmaceuticals/Thimerosal, Snoring Prevention Devices, Wheelchairs, Quad Canes, Contact Lens Solution, Orthotic Devices, Blood Pressure Machines and Laser Surgical devices.

Product Liability Prevention

We are skilled in a broad range of product safety prevention matters, such as the formation and orchestration of monthly product safety committee meetings and product liability prevention programs, record retention programs, reviews of product warnings, reviews of privilege of self-critical analysis, recall procedures and notifications, responses to agency incident reports and Freedom of Information Act requests, and internal seminars for claims departments and engineering departments.

We have significant experience concerning manufacturing operations and quality control programs. We understand that these programs are designed to result not only in the production of high-quality products, but also, when appropriate, to demonstrate to the courts that attention is being given to safety concerns both during production and in anticipation of consumer use.

We have successfully handled numerous nationwide product recalls in the United States. Our lawyers routinely counsel clients on issues involving product instructions and warnings, warranties, disclaimers, limitations of remedies, and other terms and conditions in sales, leasing, and licensing documents. A sampling of our experience follows.

  • Involvement in at least seven Voluntary Correction Actions or potential VCAs, including extensive and elaborate recall proceedings and protocols.
  • Reviewing over 100 prototype products for product safety, product testing, and warnings.
  • Authoring warnings for at least 30 products, both on product and in manual.
  • Holding in-house seminars for engineers/customer service representatives/quality controllers regarding preparation of internal documents to prevent smoking guns.
    We also have Federal Trade Commission (FTC) experience involving:
  • Authoring and critically reviewing marketing materials for 50+ products.
  • Screening websites and radio, TV, and print media programs for FTC compliance.
  • Orchestrating responses to six FTC and state attorney general investigations/inquiries, including meetings, with no enforcement actions as a result.

Given the potential for jeopardizing your company’s reputation and even its existence, product liability is an issue that deserves the highest attention—yours and ours. Trust the Benesch team to represent your interests and guide you in avoiding runaway claims and costs. With thorough knowledge of preventive practices and skillful case management and representation when needed, our attorneys will help you stay in control and out of danger.

Experience

  • Counsel for major off-road vehicles manufacturer in multiple products liability and personal injury actions in state and federal court across the United States.

  • Represented leading manufacturers of set-top devices in a nine-figure fraud and negligence dispute against a supplier. Negotiated a settlement after successfully defeating three successive motions to dismiss.
  • Represented a beef producer against product liability claims following a food contamination event. Negotiated dismissal of claims.
  • Advised a Fortune 100 seller on breach of contract claims by a purchaser relating to alleged product failures.
  • Advised leading technology manufacturer regarding response to product recall.
  • Advised manufacturer regarding damage exposure relating to potential hardware defects.
  • Represented a beef producer against contribution claims by a competitor following a food contamination event. Secured summary judgment in favor of the producer.
  • Obtained voluntary dismissal of product liability suit alleging design and manufacturing product defect in connection a hip implant.
  • Represented product manufacturer in suit alleging violations of California Proposition 65.
  • Represented medical device manufacturer in arguing that state-law product design claims were preempted under Medical Device Amendments to FDCA.
  • Represented medical device manufacturer in defense of state law design and manufacturing defect claims of heart catheter.
  • Participated in evaluation of options and actions for recalls or voluntary corrective actions for consumer and other products.
  • Prevailed on summary judgment in a sick building case in which seven plaintiffs claimed they had contracted multiple chemical sensitivity.
  • Purchased Parts Group, Inc. v. Royal Appliance Mfg. Co., 2000 WL 33125340 (Tenn. App.) Upheld order dismissing manufacturer for lack of personal jurisdiction.
  • Mutual Insurance Company of America, et al. v. Royal Appliance Mfg. Co., 112 Fed. Appx. 386 (6th Cir.) Applying rebuttable presumption of no liability to manufacturer based upon compliance with state and federal safety standards.
  • Served on the product safety committee of publicly traded global consumer product manufacturer.
  • Authored the warnings and instructions for various products.
  • Won at jury trial in a case alleging $33 million in damages for allegedly defective glazed bricks in eight high rise apartment buildings.
  • Defended a manufacturer and distributor of a variety of medical devices, including crutches, cold therapy devices, wheelchair lifts, etc.
  • Successfully defended a medical device manufacturer in a lawsuit alleging defective design and breach of warranty regarding a surgical device used during a kidney transplant.
  • Granting summary judgment on Learned Intermediary Doctrine and proximate cause in medical device case.
  • Hammod v. Alekna Construction, Inc., et al., 269 A.D. 773, 703 N.Y.S.2d 332 (N.Y.A.D. 4 2000) Sick building case, alleged multiple chemical sensitivity; dismissal affirmed.

View full team

  • Litigation
Articles and Presentations
April 23, 2018
The Application of Traditional Product Liability Law to Emerging Technologies
News
November 3, 2022
Benesch Achieves National Recognition, Including the Distinction of Law Firm of the Year in Transportation Law, in 2023 U.S. News & World Report “Best Law Firms”
November 4, 2021
Benesch Receives 58 National and Metropolitan Rankings for 2022 U.S. News - Best Lawyers® “Best Law Firms”
August 9, 2021
J. Scott Humphrey mentioned in Crain's Chicago People on the Move
  • 2025 Benesch
  • Disclaimers
  • Privacy Policy
  • Related Sites
  • GDPR Statement
  • Terms
  • Client Payment Portal
  • Careers
Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn