Client Alerts & Insights
CMS Five Star Nursing Home Quality Rating System Results Have Been Published
December 22, 2008
Authored By:
To our clients and friends:
The results of the CMS Five Star Nursing Home Quality rating system were published on December 18, 2008. The ratings of nursing homes nationwide are now accessible by all. The public can view the results at:
www.medicare.gov/NHCompare/Include/DataSection/Questions/SearchCriteriaNEW.asp
When reviewing your facility results, we urge you to analyze the results through the eyes of consumers and discharge planners, as this is the populace that will most heavily rely on the rating system.
If your facility rating is markedly different than you expected, you are not alone. There is concern and consternation throughout the industry about the flawed inspection process, the flawed data and the negative impact this faulty rating system will have on nursing facilities across the country.
National and state trade associations are questioning the accuracy and the reliability of the Five Star rating system and are examining options to remedy the flawed system. The Health Care Practice Group at Benesch Friedlander Coplan and Aronoff, LLP is monitoring the progress of the various remedial efforts and is currently exploring options available to owners and operators that are dissatisfied with their results or question the accuracy of the data utilized in determining their rating. If you are concerned about your rating and would like to discuss your options, please do not hesitate to call us.
We are examining the impact that misinformation and/or misapplied information with regard to survey results, quality measures and/or staffing measures can have on a facility’s rating. As we continue to monitor and analyze the impact of the Five Star rating system on the nursing home industry, we welcome your input. Please contact us to share your concerns and insights that will assist us in our analysis.
For more information, please contact:
Gregory G. Binford at 215.363.4617 or gbinford@beneschlaw.com
Frank W. Carsonie at 614.223.9361 or fcarsonie@beneschlaw.com
Kelly Custer at 614.223.9344 or kcuster@beneschlaw.com
Michael Distelhorst at 614.223.9386 or mdistelhorst@beneschlaw.com
Ryan P. Hooper at 216.363.4195 or rhooper@beneschlaw.com
Jayne E. Juvan at 216.363.4636 or jjuvan@beneschlaw.com
Harry M. Brown at 216.363.4606 or hbrown@beneschlaw.com
Janet K. Feldkamp at 614.223.9328 or jfeldkamp@beneschlaw.com
Beth Rosenbaum at 216.363.4519 or brosenbaum@beneschlaw.com
Alan E. Schabes at 216.363.4589 or aschabes@beneschlaw.com
Martha J. Sweterlitsch at 614.223.9367 or msweterlitsch@beneschlaw.com
Latest News
Social Media Might Have to Rethink Platform Design and Features as Courts Reject Communications Decency Act, Section 230 Defense
On April 10, 2026, on appeal from a motion to dismiss, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court held that section 230 of the Communications Decency Act did not bar Massachusetts’s claims that Meta engaged in unfair business practices by creating a platform that was addictive to teens and failing to warn the public about it.
SDNY Bankruptcy Court: Solvent Debtors Face Higher Hurdle to Avoid Default Interest Under 11 U.S.C. § 506(b)
Key Takeaways Following a recent decision from the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York, solvent debtors …
$2B Trade Secrets Verdict Overturned by the Virginia Supreme Court
Recently, the Virginia Supreme Court vacated a $2B jury award and ordered a new trial in a state trade secrets action. The justices held that the circuit court judge made four significant errors leading to Virginia’s largest jury award. Significantly, according to the justices, the circuit court judge put an improper burden of proof on defendants to show that its sales were unrelated to the misappropriation to avoid plaintiff being awarded defendant’s full sales revenue as opposed to the plaintiff having the burden to show defendant’s actions proximately caused plaintiff’s damages.
Ohio Senate Introduces Bipartisan Bill to Establish Paid Family and Medical Leave
On April 23, 2026, a new bipartisan bill was introduced in the Ohio Senate that would provide paid family and medical leave to Ohio workers. Sponsored by Democrat Beth Litson and Republican Louis W. Blessing III, Senate Bill 396 largely mirrors programs already established in several other states, including California and New York.