Overview
Michael Montgomery litigates differently. Before advocating for a client, Michael listens intently so that he fully understands what a successful outcome in any given dispute looks like for his client. And then he drives himself to deliver that result.
This involves far more than a “paint-by-numbers” approach to litigation. Unafraid to challenge convention, Michael brings a creative perspective to his advocacy that helps his clients resolve disputes without wasting their time and money. He stays in close contact with his clients throughout a dispute—never billing his time for providing frequent updates—so that he can deftly change course if a new strategy is necessary to achieve the right result. Although no one wants to find themselves in a legal dispute, Michael partners with his clients to help them navigate the litigation process as painlessly as possible, and he takes the time to counsel his clients to help them avoid getting entangled in litigation moving forward.
Michael has the tools to clear the high bar of excellence he sets for himself in every matter. After graduating in the top one percent of his law school class (and scoring in the top one percent among his fellow bar examinees), he spent three years as a law clerk for two federal judges at both the trial and appellate levels. Michael has now spent more than two decades applying his knowledge and insights to bring wins to his clients in trials and appeals all over the United States. He has done so in a staggeringly wide range of matters, including everything from high-stakes commercial disputes and product-liability actions to complex environmental litigation and actions to recover assets for Ponzi scheme victims.
But Michael strives to accomplish more than successful outcomes for his clients. Legal disputes are inevitably challenging and stressful for everyone involved. With this in mind, Michael treats everyone involved in the legal process with unfailing kindness and genuine respect. He is also known for cracking a joke from time to time, and he remains certain one of them will eventually elicit laughter in response.
*Matter completed prior to joining Benesch.
Featured endorsements
Experience
Served as lead appellate counsel in proceedings arising from a range of litigation.*
Successfully defended a major shipping company in a jury trial on a contract claim that sought to impose a multi-million dollar obligation for hauling services.*
Provided counsel in litigation throughout the United States aimed to recover misappropriated funds in the largest Ponzi scheme in history.*
Secured multiple favorable settlements of multi-million dollar product-liability lawsuits brought against a major vehicle manufacturer throughout the United States.
Led team that successfully defended a $60 million claim for breach of a brand-license agreement following a multi-week arbitration hearing.
Manages key elements of high-profile defamation litigation against major media outlets featuring claims for more than $2 billion in damages.
Serves as primary litigation counsel for national commercial-property management firm involving a range of leasing and related disputes.
Prevented a business competitor from obtaining an injunction to stop construction of a $200 million industrial facility.*
Played a lead role in securing a $32.9 million verdict for a bankruptcy trustee following a lengthy trial on a breach-of-contract claim arising from a Ponzi scheme.*
Secured a multimillion-dollar verdict following a jury trial in a dispute involving a series of complex software-license agreements.*
Obtained a multimillion-dollar settlement on behalf of a Fortune 500 electronics manufacturer in a lawsuit for breach of an intellectual property license.*
Defeated a regulatory challenge to an air permit for a new $1.3 billion steel-making facility following a lengthy administrative hearing and subsequent appeal.*
Successfully defended major consumer-product company in a securities class action aimed at derailing a $500 million going-private transaction.*
Negotiated a series of settlements on behalf of a software developer arising from other entities’ misuse of the client’s software.*
Secured a multimillion-dollar settlement on behalf of an oil and gas exploration company arising from a mineral rights lease.*
Successfully defended a Fortune 500 media company in a jury trial on a $17 million claim for breach of a long-term supply contract.*
Successfully defended international construction cocompany in a series of contract disputes.*
No results found
Credentials
Education
- Articles Editor, The Ohio State Law Journal
- summa cum laude
- Order of the Coif
- magna cum laude
Clerkships and Bar Admissions
More
- Law Clerk to the Honorable James S. Gwin, United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio (1999-2001)
- Law Clerk to the Honorable Ronald L. Gilman, United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit (2001-2002)
- Member, American Bar Association
- Federal Bar Association
- Northern Ohio Chapter: Board of Directors
- Member, Cleveland Metropolitan Bar Association
- Northern District of Ohio Advisory Group: Appointed Member (2017)
- Cleveland Marshall College of Law: Adjunct Professor of Law
- Merit Selection Panel for the Reappointment of a U.S. Magistrate Judge: Member
- Delegate, Sixth Circuit Judicial Conference
- Listed, The Best Lawyers in America®, Commercial Litigation, 2018-2026
- Martindale-Hubbell: AV Preeminent
Related News & Insights
129 Benesch Attorneys Recognized in 2026 Best Lawyers® Rankings
Benesch is proud to announce that the firm has been recognized in the 2026 edition of Best Lawyers in America®. …
Michael Montgomery Mentioned in Law360 on Dismissal of GrafTech Shareholder Lawsuit
Benesch Partner Michael Montgomery was mentioned in Law360 in connection with an Ohio federal judge’s decision to dismiss a shareholder …
132 Benesch Attorneys Recognized in 2025 Best Lawyers® Rankings
Benesch is proud to announce that the firm has been recognized in the 2025 edition of Best Lawyers in America®. …
Benesch Continues Expansion of National Litigation Practice
Benesch is pleased to announce that high-profile litigators Michael J. Montgomery and Michael D. Meuti have joined the Cleveland office. …