Caitlin is an experienced complex commercial litigator who specializes in the most challenging and significant matters her clients face.
She leads effective teams on bet-the-company cases in both state and federal courts involving disputes of all kinds, including breach of contract, fraud, business torts, defamation, white collar, products liability, restructuring, False Claims Act, antitrust, and tax. Her clients span a wide range of industries and include Fortune 100 financial institutions, retail institutions, chemical companies, and technology companies.
Caitlin’s advocacy and problem-solving skills have been consistently praised by clients and co-counsel alike, who describe her as a “super smart, dedicated,” and “very, very formidable” attorney. Her “extremely persuasive” writing skills have been described as “terrific” and “really powerful,” and consistently lead to early resolution of her client’s disputes. When disputes proceed to discovery, her “wonderful” legal strategy, “exceptional” handling of witnesses, and “poised, expert and persuasive” oral advocacy put her clients in an excellent position to win. Jurors have also praised Caitlin as an “excellent” presenter whose style is “confident,” “very knowledgeable and passionate,” “detailed yet simple to understand,” and “just the right amount of everything.”
An engaging speaker, Caitlin is often invited to instruct on a variety of legal issues. She teaches programs on ethics issues facing in-house counsel, deposition skills, and women in the law.
*Matters completed prior to joining Benesch.
Representative Experience
- Representing a global election technology firm in a defamation suit seeking over $2 billion against Fox News and others.
- Counsel for international oil company in putative class action arising out of the storage of its petroleum product. Won motion to dismiss all six claims.*
- Represented major vehicle manufacturer in DOJ and SEC investigation involving fraud allegations.*
- Secured summary judgment for global investment management firm in over half a billion-dollar defamation case involving the high yield municipal bond market.*
- Counsel for major home furnishings retailer in purported class actions involving allegations of product defect, consumer fraud, and warrantability claims. Won motion to compel arbitration following contested evidentiary hearing.*
- Counsel for multinational recreational vehicle manufacturer in putative class actions and personal injury matters alleging product liability and violations of consumer protection statutes.*
- Counsel for major power company in case brought by energy services competitor alleging theft of confidential information and unfair business practices. During deposition discovery, sought and won a stay of the preliminary injunction proceeding on behalf of client. Case settled favorably during stay. *
- Represented major chemical company in SEC investigation into federal reporting issues. *
- Counsel for major international airline in litigation arising out of spacecraft venture. In 2016, after six years of litigation in four countries, the airline won summary judgment as plaintiff against three companies controlled by the Russian and Ukrainian governments. The total judgment in plaintiff’s favor exceeded $500 million. This victory was recognized by The American Lawyer as a Transatlantic Litigation matter of the year for 2016. *
- Represented a multinational medical device company in internal investigation involving allegations of potential kickbacks and off-label marketing.*
